Citrus Heights Sentinel Logo

Guest Opinion: Rent control would be bad for Citrus Heights

Guest opinion by Sacramento County Supervisor Sue Frost–
It is quite rare to see economists largely agree with each other on governmental policy. While economists are supposed to be non-partisan and purely scientific, that’s not really how it works in practice.

Sue Frost, supervisor
Sue Frost

Often times you can have well-respected economists taking radically different positions on the same subject. So for an issue that has 0% of economists strongly supporting it, according to a University of Chicago business school survey of 40 of America’s leading economic experts, one would think that the concept of rent control would similarly have zero political support. Yet, as you read this, efforts are underway to bring rent control to California, which would directly impact Citrus Heights.

Rent control can sound good on the surface — rent gets set at a fair price and can only be raised by modest percentages so renters aren’t priced out of their homes with huge rent increases that they cannot afford.

Proponents will argue that low income families don’t have enough options for where to live as it is, and that having to find a new home can be devastating (in some cases lead to homelessness). But while these proponents are correct, their proposed solution to this growing issue unfortunately magnifies the problem.

The amount that property owners charge for rent is largely dependent on market forces. If the demand for rooms is low and supply is high, then rents decrease to ensure that owners are able to keep vacancy rates as low as possible. Conversely, if the demand for rooms is high and supply is low (as is the case currently) then the rents increase as more people compete for less units.

If the government imposes restrictions on property owners and forces them to offer lower rents than the market would otherwise dictate, we see two incredibly negative things immediately happen:

First, no new housing will be built and in some cases, housing will be torn down and replaced with other uses (like commercial business). By forcing rents below the market price, rent control reduces the profitability of rental housing, directing investment capital out of the rental market and into other more profitable markets. In a situation where there is already a lack of housing options, this is about the worst thing that can happen. If the quantity of housing options does not keep pace with population increases, the problem is greatly exacerbated.

Second, due to diminishing profits for property owners and an increase in demand, they are no longer financially able to perform proper upkeep of the property or to quickly respond to requests for repair. The quality of the properties quickly decline and that is not a positive thing for the renter, or for the community of Citrus Heights who has to live with deteriorating buildings in their neighborhood.

In places where there is demand for more housing, a more effective policy is to simply build more housing. The challenge then becomes how to reduce the cost of construction, where to site the housing, and how to implement affordable housing programs in a way that works for the neighboring communities.

But in order to keep our housing affordable, we can’t create policies that sound good on paper but make the situation worse – we have to come up with long term solutions if we ever want to fix things.

Sacramento County Supervisor Sue Frost formerly served as a Citrus Heights councilwoman and currently represents District 4, which includes Citrus Heights. She can be contacted at (916) 874-5491, or SupervisorFrost@saccounty.net.

The Sentinel welcomes guest opinion columns and letters to the editor written by local residents. Click here to submit your own for publication.

Like local news? Sign up for The Sentinel’s free email edition and get two emails a week with all local news and no spam, ever. (Click here)